Premier League Analysis · Manchester City
Eight Weeks Without Semenyo; One Unassigned City Role
Antoine Semenyo was City's planned alternative to Erling Haaland. His eight-week absence makes the identity and instructions of the second No. 9 an immediate coaching decision.
Eight weeks removed the easy answer
Antoine Semenyo's knee injury did more than take a winger from Manchester City's rotation. Enzo Maresca had identified him as the player who could move inside when Erling Haaland needed a break. Eight weeks without Semenyo therefore removes a specific contingency just as Haaland is being assessed after taking a knock in the 3-2 win over Ipswich.
City have started the league with seven straight wins. Haaland scored twice against Ipswich, Phil Foden scored the first goal from Jérémy Doku's cutback and the attack still produced enough to survive a late penalty. The temptation is to treat the missing contingency as a problem for another week. The schedule argues otherwise: City entered a run of seven games in 21 days, and Maresca made six changes against Ipswich before a Champions League match with AEK Athens.
The decision is not whether anybody can imitate Haaland. Nobody in this squad can. It is which player receives a smaller, explicit version of the striker job before necessity makes the experiment public.
Separate the role from the name
A second No. 9 plan needs three instructions. First, occupy both centre-backs often enough that City's attacking midfielders can receive facing goal. Second, make one repeatable run across the near defender when the ball reaches the byline. Third, begin the press from a position that sends the opponent toward City's stronger side. Those tasks can be coached even when Haaland's finishing and penalty-box gravity cannot be copied.
Foden is the cleaner option when City want an extra midfielder between the lines. Iliman Ndiaye offers a different route, with more appetite to run behind and pull a defender away from the ball. Neither choice has to become a permanent hierarchy. Maresca can define two versions: Foden for a match that needs another connector, Ndiaye for one that needs depth against a higher line.
That clarity matters to the players around the substitute as much as to the substitute himself. A false nine who drops requires a winger to attack the six-yard box. A runner who stays high requires a midfielder to connect the build-up. Calling both solutions 'different options' leaves the costly decisions until the ball is moving.
The strongest case for waiting
There is a reasonable objection. Haaland may be available against AEK, City are winning, and rearranging an attack to prepare for an absence can make the best side less direct. Semenyo's injury is expected to last about eight weeks, not a season. Maresca could manage Haaland's minutes, use him to establish leads and postpone the improvised-striker question until the match state is safer.
But managed minutes still require somebody to play the final half-hour. They also require that player to recognise the occupation and pressing cues without a full training week. Marc Guéhi described a schedule built around recovery and games rather than long tactical sessions. Waiting does not preserve simplicity; it reduces the rehearsal time available for the inevitable substitution.
City also lost to Paris Saint-Germain before beating Ipswich. Europe has already supplied the warning that domestic momentum does not settle every game state. A vague backup role is easiest to ignore while the first-choice striker is scoring. That is precisely when it is cheapest to define.
Use AEK as the rehearsal
AEK arrive at the Etihad on Tuesday with City trying to recover their European position. The match is meaningful, so any rehearsal must remain conditional on the score and Haaland's fitness. If he starts and City establish control, choose the replacement before kickoff and reserve a real window rather than three ceremonial minutes. If he does not, make the role explicit from the opening press.
The useful evidence will not be whether Foden or Ndiaye scores. Watch who pins the centre-backs when City's wide player receives, who attacks the first post, and whether the first defender turns AEK's buildup toward a planned trap. Those actions reveal whether the solution belongs to the team or only to the name on the lineup sheet.
Semenyo can return around December with energy and a defined route back into the rotation. Until then, City should not spend Haaland's health to avoid naming his deputy. Seven league wins have bought Maresca room to prepare. AEK should be where he uses it.
Keep the signal alive
What comes next
Follow the team or writer, then come back for the next consequential game and argument.
New results and original stories will roll into My Sports.
