CincinnatiTeam hub

MLS Analysis · FC Cincinnati

Evander, Denkey and the Cost of Cincinnati's Caution

Evander and Kévin Denkey drove nearly half of Cincinnati's goals. The Orlando wild card should connect their jobs instead of letting the ninth seed dictate caution.

Ninth is a bracket slot, not an attacking identity

A ninth seed is a position in a bracket, not a discount on two Designated Players. FC Cincinnati finished the regular season by losing 2-0 at home to Nashville and sliding to ninth in the Eastern Conference. That result sends them to Orlando for a single-elimination match on November 19. It does not require them to arrive dressed as a ninth seed.

Cincinnati and Orlando both finished on 46 points. Cincinnati also went unbeaten in the two regular-season meetings, winning 6-2 in May and drawing 1-1 in August. Those results do not grant a playoff advantage, but they remove one excuse: Pat Noonan's side do not need to invent a timid new identity to make the matchup respectable.

The first decision should connect the two Designated Players who carried the attack. Evander finished with 14 goals and 17 assists; Kévin Denkey produced 17 goals and five assists. MLS credits the pair with nearly half of Cincinnati's goals. A knockout game is an expensive place to discover your two best attackers have been assigned separate emergencies.

One pass should create two Orlando problems

Evander's job should begin between Orlando's midfield and back line, close enough to Denkey that one forward pass forces two defensive choices. If a centre-back follows Denkey toward the ball, Evander receives beyond the midfielder. If the defender protects depth, Denkey can set the pass and turn the next runner into the threat.

That picture sounds simple because two Designated Player slots are supposed to make the expensive part simple. Cincinnati did not commit both of them so each could solve a different broken possession from 30 yards apart. The value appears when one player's movement improves the other's decision.

The 6-2 win in May is useful evidence without becoming a script. Evander scored twice, Denkey scored and Cincinnati kept attacking after Orlando had twice narrowed the margin. The lesson is not that six goals are waiting in Florida. It is that the two stars can occupy the same aggressive game without taking turns being the whole attack.

Caution has an honest case

Five months have passed since the six-goal match. Orlando recovered enough to finish above Cincinnati and earn the home field. A one-game playoff punishes the turnover that a regular-season shootout can absorb. Noonan has a reasonable case for protecting the centre, lowering the early risk and letting the match become a test of patience.

The August draw strengthens that caution. Orlando changed the terms after May and Cincinnati did not reproduce the same flood. Repeating the spring lineup positions as if the first result were a cheat code would be nostalgia in a tactical jacket.

But caution should govern the distances behind Evander and Denkey, not the distance between them. Cincinnati can keep a midfielder connected to the centre-backs and still place its two best producers in the same attacking lane. Protecting transition does not require turning Denkey into a lonely clearance target or Evander into a rescue service.

Spend the risk where the stars connect

The ninth seed is evidence that Cincinnati's regular-season balance did not hold. The response cannot be to ask the two designated attacking stars to cover that weakness by working in separate possessions. That merely moves the shortage into the part of the roster built to decide matches.

Noonan has to choose where the roster will spend its risk. Keeping Evander near Denkey may leave one fewer body in the first line of protection, but separating them makes every recovery longer and every lost clearance more likely to return. Connected attacking players can be a defensive tool because they give the team somewhere to keep the ball.

This is the opportunity-cost test. If Cincinnati add a cautious midfielder but remove Evander from Denkey's next action, what exactly has the extra security purchased? A lower block that cannot exit is not secure. It is a waiting room with shin pads.

Twenty minutes can settle the decision

The opening 20 minutes in Orlando should answer three questions. Can Evander receive on the same vertical line as Denkey? Does Denkey's first movement create a forward option rather than only contest a long ball? Is one Cincinnati midfielder close enough to collect the failed connection without dragging the whole back line forward?

If the answers are yes, Cincinnati can adjust the height without abandoning the partnership. If Orlando block the inside pass, the outside runner should gain room. If they follow Evander, Denkey should have the channel. One connected threat forces choices; two isolated stars merely wait for mistakes.

A win would send Cincinnati into a series with Supporters' Shield winner Nashville, the team that pushed them into ninth place. That consequence can wait. If Orlando can keep Evander and Denkey in separate games for the first 20 minutes, Cincinnati will have let the seed choose for them.

Keep the signal alive

What comes next

Follow the team or writer, then come back for the next consequential game and argument.

Your briefingKeep Cincinnati in view

New results and original stories will roll into My Sports.

Next on the calendarFC Cincinnati at Orlando CityOpen game center →
Refresh this page ✕